How historically accurate is Platoon?

HISTORICAL ACCURACY: The film does not claim to be a true story, although Stone made no secret of it being autobiographical in spots. Barnes and Elias were based on two of Stone’s sergeants, but they were not in the same platoon.

Is Platoon a propaganda?

Although Rollins labels the film as left-wing, anti-war propaganda, he gives Platoon high marks for its realistic landscape and perilous environment. He has an OSU class in film criticism.

Is the movie We Were Soldiers historically accurate?

Then came the 2002 movie, We Were Soldiers, starring Mel Gibson as Moore and Barry Pepper as Galloway. (Moore says the film is about 60 percent accurate; Galloway, 80 percent.) They also apply the lessons of Vietnam to Iraq—where Galloway, now a columnist for McClatchy Newspapers, sees more fatal victories.

What battle was the movie Platoon based on?

Vietnam War
The New Year’s Day battle of 1968 was a military engagement during the Vietnam War that began on the evening of 1 January 1968.

Was Val Kilmer in the movie Platoon?

Val Kilmer auditioned for the role of Sergeant Elias. According to Oliver Stone, he gave a bizarre audition, where he portrayed the character as an Indian shaman. At one point, Junior and several other black soldiers are talking about the situation in the platoon.

Is Apocalypse Now historically accurate?

HISTORICAL ACCURACY: “Apocalypse Now” is not meant to be historically accurate. None of the events are based on actual happenings. Some bend over backwards to find historical persons in some of the characters, but that is a waste of time.

Was Val Kilmer in the movie platoon?

Is platoon an accurate depiction of the Vietnam War?

Despite its initial acclaim, however, Platoon has proven divisive in the years since its release, with some critics claiming the movie offers an inaccurate depiction of the Vietnam invasion.

Is platoon a good movie about war?

Platoon portrays war as psychological and physical hell from which no one can escape unscathed, and in that regard, it stands alongside Full Metal Jacket and Jarhead in terms of accurately depicting the everyday reality of an inhuman atrocity. Cathal Gunning has been writing about movies and TV online since 2020.

Is Stone’s Platoon based on a true story?

Stone’s Platoon was promoted as the first Vietnam film made by a real-life veteran of the war, and more than lives up to that promise.

Is platoon about drug and alcohol use?

Platoon is a caricature of Vietnam. Drug and alcohol use wasn’t nearly as prominent as the film makes out–that was mostly done, if at all, in rear units and not by the actual troops in the field with their lives on the line. In a book that was written by someone who served with my uncle in the war (in 1969) it mentions two guys using drugs once.