Q&A

What are the reasons editors reject papers?

by Author

What are the reasons editors reject papers?

Reasons why a paper can get rejected:

  • Out of scope.
  • Lacking state-of-the-art overview.
  • Lack of originality.
  • Lack of conclusion.
  • Flaws in research design or methods.
  • Unclear research question.
  • Redundant publication.
  • Lack of relevance.

Why are scientific papers rejected?

The reasons for a paper being rejected once it has been reviewed fall mainly into two categories: (1) problems with the research; and (2) problems with the writing/presentation of the paper. A paper may be rejected because of problems with the research on which it is based.

What are the most popular reasons editors usually reject your paper for?

READ:   Is there a dating site that actually works?

These are some of the common technical reasons for which papers are rejected:

  • Research doesn’t add value to the journal.
  • Unclear hypothesis.
  • Lack of supporting evidence.
  • Poor Analysis.
  • Wrong research methodology.
  • Inconclusive result.
  • Violation of research ethics.

How many scientific papers are retracted?

The data confirm that the absolute number of retractions has risen over the past few decades, from fewer than 100 annually before 2000 to nearly 1000 in 2014. But retractions remain relatively rare: Only about four of every 10,000 papers are now retracted.

How many times does a paper get rejected?

Several studies suggest that at least 20 percent of published articles were first rejected by another journal. An older study found that about 1 percent of published articles were rejected by four or more journals before being accepted.

What are the things that you will consider before submitting your article to a journal?

3 things to consider before writing your journal article

  • Write about your interests. “You must be passionate about what you write about.
  • Have a firm grasp on your field’s dominant theories.
  • Check the journals guidelines.
READ:   Should genetically modified crops be introduced to Africa?

Who approves or rejects the manuscript?

About 20-30\% of the manuscripts can very quickly be categorized as unsuitable or beyond the scope of the journal. The Editor-in-Chief has the discretion to reject the manuscript straight off even before sending it to the reviewers for reviewing.

Can a research proposal be rejected?

In many cases, a foundation or government agency will reject a proposal because they do not believe that any new information will be produced as a result. Some research proposal rejection is based upon the requirements for personnel and equipment.

How many scientific studies are published each year?

How many scientific journals are published globally per year? No one knows how many scientific journals there are, but several estimates point to around 30,000, with close to two million articles published each year.

When should you retract a paper?

Retraction is a mechanism for correcting the literature and alerting readers to publications that contain such seriously flawed or erroneous data that their findings and conclusions cannot be relied upon. Unreliable data may result from honest error or from research misconduct.

READ:   Can a cloud server crash?

What is the average rejection rate for the top journals?

However, it may not be appreciated by editors and reviewers when the research is submitted to a journal for publication. One should not get disappointed by rejections. Most top journals have almost 80\% rejection rates.

How do I submit a journal?

Top tips

  1. Read the journal’s aims and scope to make sure it is a match.
  2. Check whether you can submit – some journals are invitation only.
  3. Use journal metrics to understand the impact of a journal.
  4. If available, check the journal at Journal Insights for additional info about impact, speed and reach.